I’m the Catholic matchmaker who believes in your love life! Finally, a wholesome approach to meet someone with similar values in God’s timing!!

If you’ve tried everything—dating apps, secular matchmakers, speed dating and still haven’t found your person, I believe Catholic matchmaking can be a faithful, human-first way to meet someone worth building a life with.

Madigan, founder of CommitmentISM, laughs while holding a vintage phone, conveying warmth, approachability, and an open invitation to connect.

What Inspired
Catholic Matchmaking?

In 2019, I moved to Dallas for work and spent a lot of time traveling. I tried the secular apps in different cities—and deleted them every time I landed. I hated turning Young Adult events into dating opportunities instead of places to build real community.

My breaking point came when I signed up for CatholicMatch and realized I had to pay just to talk to someone, with no indication whether or not we’d even be right for each other.

On a Labor Day retreat, I brought it all to prayer. And very clearly, the Lord said: Make better.

So I did.

I launched an in-person Catholic matchmaking business two weeks before the country shut down. Timing has never been my strong suit—LOL—but obedience usually makes up for it.

What changed the way I see dating

After stepping away to heal from a deeply broken relationship, I started paying attention to shows like Love Is Blind and Married at First Sight. Not for the drama—but for the truth hidden underneath.

When you remove physical attraction at the beginning, something surprising happens. People listen better. They show up more honestly. They form real connection first.

That insight became the foundation of Conversational Chemistry—and it changed everything.

Madigan kneels in prayer before the altar in a Catholic church, reflecting discernment, reverence, and prayerful care for her matchmaking work.

CommitmentISM values

C — Catholic.

Faith is non-negotiable here. It’s Catholic only and we work with individuals who prioritize their faith.

I — Intentional.

We only work with people who are serious about marriage. We want those who are free to marry and open to children.

S — Serendipitous.

This is all within God’s perfect timing and we trust that. When it works, we give glory and honor to His beautiful love story (and Madigan gets an invite to the wedding!)

M — Matchmaking.

Human-to-human connection rooted in rich tradition and understanding of humans, not an algorithm

Ready to experience a more human way to meet?

Madigan’s hands holding a rosary in prayer, representing her commitment to discernment and prayerful guidance for each match.

Our Patron Saints

Saints Zelie and Louis Martin

Patron saints of Marriages & Parenting

Mother to St. Therese of Lisieux

Pray for Us!

Our Mission

We believe that healthy, authentic relationships

Between hopeful, romantic Catholics

Will change humanity for good

Who is Matchmaker Madigan?

Pronounced “Mad again”, like how you might feel about your love life right now, but I’m here to make you Happy Again!

I’m human; very, very human

My Faith Life: Cradle Catholic, encountered a relationship with Christ at Catholic Youth Camp in 8th grade, Franciscan University of Steubenville graduate, Former Young Catholic Professionals President, Former Catholic Radio Host & Adoration Lover!

My Relationships: Daughter to Happily Married Parents, Oldest Sister in the fam bam, Best friend to 30+ people & Newly Married Wife

In My Fun Time: Concert Lover, Dance Floor Starter, Fun outfit Connoisseur & Your Future Wedding Coordinator (if you’ll let me!)

My superpower for matchmaking: Seeing people the way God sees them & sharing hope with singles!

You don’t need another app. You need a wingwoman.

My promise to you..

is that I’ll never introduce you to someone unless I genuinely believe you could marry them.

That belief might come from a profile, a conversation, a moment of clarity in prayer, or something you said in a one-on-one.

However it happens, you have my word: my primary concern is finding you a spouse, not making introductions in order to hit quotas.

I’ve got my happy dance ready for when you decide to commit to your love life!